RV Slide-Outs - The Good and the Bad

We had sold our motor coach some time ago andthe season to reduce the probability of mechanical
thought we would just sit things out for a while.mishaps while traveling. If it appears there may be a
RVing, however, is very addictive. We missed beingproblem with a slide-out staying properly retracted
able to just go where and when we wished towhile the vehicle is traveling, mechanical locks can be
(weather permitting) and all the friends we hadfitted to ensure complete retraction is maintained.
accumulated during all our previous years of RVing.Intrusion of debris
Should we get slide-outsThe problem of pulling debris inside the RV when
We had decided on a fifth wheel trailer having triedretracting the slide-out is not a problem with the fifth
out several loaned by our dealer (he even loaned uswheels we had been considering because they all are
the pickup to pull them) and were truly converted tofitted with special awnings which extend and retract
this new (to us) type of RV. The one big decisionwith the slide-outs.
remaining was the matter of slide-outs, -- those boxMaintenance of actuating mechanism
like structures which were made to extend from theProper maintenance by the dealer helps to assure the
RV (when parked) and provided much appreciatedelectrical motors and associated gears work properly
additional space inside the vehicle. Our salesman hadwhen they are expected to but, if something were
explained to us how they worked but would not giveto happen there is a mechanical override to allow the
us any recommendations. He did, however, give us aslide-out to be retracted manually. He also said that
list of folks who had bought fifth wheel trailers withmost problems of this nature occur because the
slide-outs.trailer wasn't leveled before the slide-outs were
What we found on the Internetextended.
First, we thought, we would just see what we couldAdditional maintenance costs
find on the Internet. It was overwhelming! Mostly,The expected additional maintenance cost only
we found complaints -- the same complaints overoccurs in his dealership if something has to be
and over again. How could anything be this bad andrepaired. The inspections, lubrication of seals, gears,
still be so popular?etc., is done by his mechanics when the RV is
The six major complaintsbrought in for its annual checkup.
The more important complaints included:Structural integrity
* leaking of water and dust around the gaskets thatThe structural integrity is more a function of the size
are supposed to seal the slide-out when extended orof the slide-out. The fifth wheel trailers we were
retracted.considering were not compromised by the inclusion of
* accumulation of debris on the top of the slide-outsthe slide-outs.
when parked under trees (which is where the shadeReduction of carrying capacity
is!) being pulled into the RV when the slide-outs areThe matter of reduction of carrying capacity brought
retracteda smile to his face: "It's a matter of numbers. You
* malfunction of the mechanisms responsible forcan carry so much and that is the limit. So you have
extending and retracting the slide-out (a real problemto decide what is important and stay within the limit.
if they're extended and can't be retracted)The slide-outs in the units you have looked at are on
* additional maintenance cost (especially as the RVthe light side (about 600 pounds each) because they
ages)are small and not moving appliances."
* compromised structural integrity of the body ofAgain he encouraged us to check with other
the RVcustomers who had fifth wheel trailers with slide-outs.
* reduction of carrying capacity of RV due to extraWe hadn't wanted to bother his customers but
weight of the slide-outs (500 to as much as 1000decided that, as people complain more readily than
pounds per slide-out).they praise -- especially on the Internet, we should
After reading all this stuff on the Internet we weretake his advice.
ready to say 'no' to slide-outs. We didn't haveWhat other owners had to say
slide-outs on the MCI or Flxible; can they really beWe did check with all the people on his list. Without
that great?exception, all were very happy -- not only with the
The salesman's answersslide-outs but with the trailers and the service they
We went back to the salesman and he again pointedhad received. We were convinced so we bought the
out that nearly all of their Fifth Wheels now come31 foot Cardinal with the living area plus front
with slide-outs. Depreciation is much greater for unitsbedroom (and queen-sized bed) slide-outs. We've had
without slide-outs. He did have some rebuttalsour Cardinal over 2 years, so far, and expect to have
concerning the complaints we had gathered.it a few more.
Water leakageOur decision
The cited water leakage problem is almost alwaysSlide-outs, good or bad? They're great! Ours change
due to lack of proper maintenance. There areliving in a hallway into enjoying our living room and
lubricants which, when properly applied to thebeing able to get into our queen bed from both sides.
rubber-like gaskets, prolong the useful lives of theSo what if diesel is $5 a gallon... RVing is that
gaskets. And, like your automobile (or pickup truck)addictive!
the RV should be checked out at the beginning of